iSugio

Waiting in the Summer – Review

by Miguel Douglas

@isugoi

share share

While testing his 8mm camera at night, Kaito Kirishima is caught amid a mysterious explosion in his small town. Strangely, Kaito wakes up the next day perfectly fine, but with no recollection of what exactly happened the day before. Unfazed by what seems to have been just a dream, he heads to school not giving much thought to the incident. Discussing with his friends about the camera, they decide to make a movie during summer break. They invite two upper-class students to participate in the project: recently arrived Ichika Takatsuki and the odd Remon Yamano. In a strange twist of fate, Ichika starts living with Kaito as his sister has to work overseas. Summer days are about to get exciting for the small film crew.

With a screenplay written by Yosuke Kuroda, Waiting in the Summer is a series that attempts to offer an original approach towards its narrative, but also easily befalls to the numerous tropes of the romantic comedy genre within anime. With its usage of a female extraterrestrial love interest, various risqué shots of its female cast, and a rather predicable harem-esque plot line, the series contains a multitude of familiar elements that viewers of this particular genre will have seen before within other works. This is interesting considering that one of Kuroda’s most famous contributions within his career was that of being the screenwriter for Please Teacher! (2002), in which one has to wonder if a return to a similar genre such as the one in that show would be detrimental to Kuroda’s ability to expand as a writer, distancing himself from his prior approach of construing romanticism with the likes of fetishism. Unfortunately, Waiting in the Summer returns to almost the exact themes he’d focused on in previous works—excluding much of the creativity that made works such as Please Teacher! original for its time.

The common premise of an alien girl unexpectedly coming to earth and intermingling with that of humans is certainly not a new concept in the slightest—it’s one of the most overly utilized themes within anime. What makes Waiting in the Summer somewhat frustrating is that Kuroda already showcased this theme within his previous works, including that of the aforementioned Please Teacher!, a work that is almost identical to the premise established here. This approach doesn’t necessarily help the series in regards to providing a unique take on a rather conventional theme, instead relying on the tired tropes that have thus hindered this concept from expanding in a creative fashion. In other words, the premise of an alien girl falling in love with an earthling boy has increasingly become a gimmick within anime, a mere narrative device in which a story is constructed around. A major problem within Waiting in the Summer is that the series never truly expands on this premise to any significant standard, gradually keeping it in the background without much effort to sustain it as a reasonable facet of its story.

This approach can almost be expected of Kuroda considering his past works, where such contrivances were used to a substantial degree. This can further be seen within this series, where the idea of the alien girl Ichika is not that as forthcoming as a major element of the plot, and where the main focus is shifted to that of the romantic relationships between the characters. This positions the subject of Ichika being an alien as seemingly an afterthought, a move that makes its inclusion more apparent as a gimmick as series progresses. But if this was a plot device to simply focus upon the relationships of its characters, it doesn’t fare much better. The relationship between Kaito and Ichika is oddly forced; the series makes no appreciable attempt to make these two characters seem compatible whatsoever—unless you take into account that Kaito’s only mainly attracted to Ichika’s physical appearance, a notion the series continuously lends its attention towards. The series extends this approach towards other characters as well, in turn becoming an unnecessary labyrinth of emotionally vulnerable individuals subscribing to a complex model of conflicting love interests i.e. boy likes girl, but another girl also really likes the boy, but the boy doesn’t like her, but he kind of likes another girl too, and then that third girl comes to like another boy and him, etc., with the end result of the viewer just wishing these characters would come clean and simply admit their love for one another.

Thematically though, one could appreciate that the series does deal with some important issues regarding the fleeting passing of youth and first love. Waiting in the Summer puts special emphasis on these two elements, making the series more relatable on a purely sentimental level than anything. We slowly begin to understand these characters actions and how they correlate with their growing love and closeness towards one another. There is a palpable sense of friendship that the series adheres to as well, where sacrificing one’s interest for another is a real sign of true friendship, and where respecting the pursuits of a friend’s love interest is both admirable and courageous. In many ways, Waiting in the Summer would’ve been a much more appropriate series if it just focused more extensively on the aspects of teenage love and companionship rather than interject the whole concept of Ichika being an extraterrestrial from a faraway planet. While that certainly provides the series a touch of uniqueness, the connection between the characters is the series’ main strength—not its extraterrestrial women or galactic skirmishes. Kaito and Ichika’s relationship—as faulty as it is—gives the series some pertinence towards the notion of falling in love with someone you know you can’t be with. Director Tatsuyuki Nagai handles this aspect of the series with considerable attention, never allowing the emotions of the show’s characters to deteriorate into adolescent melodrama.

This approach is where Waiting in the Summer works out extremely well, and where the series finds itself rising slightly above its conventional premise. But the most significant detriment within the series is that it’s relies on all-to-known conceptual traits to advance its story, which alleviates it from eliciting any real emotional response offered through its characters. The added element of Ichika being an extraterrestrial seemingly has no effect on the outcome of the story, instead only utilized for purposes of strangely reinforcing her physical relationship with Kaito—with one prime example of her having to kiss him in order to deliver nanomachines to his body. One aspect of the series that is quite accomplished though is the development of its characters, which can certainly be accredited to Kuroda’s skills as a writer. If the series didn’t involve itself within the realm of the supernatural, it would’ve worked out great as a simple romantic comedy regarding one character’s willingness to direct a film with friends against the backdrop of a transitory summer. While the viewers may appreciate the series’ character development, other elements just seem as an unnecessary distraction more than anything, making Waiting in the Summer a series that awkwardly subscribes to both a tired premise as well as considerable character development—with neither one truly complementing the other.

Be Sociable, Share!

Author: Miguel Douglas

As an avid viewer of both Japanese animation and cinema for more than a decade now, Miguel is primarily concerned with establishing a critical look into both mediums as legitimate forms of artistic, cultural, and societal understanding. Never one to simply look at a film or series based solely on superficiality, Miguel has dedicated himself towards bringing awareness to Asian entertainment and its various facets.

Latest Additions

The World of Kanako – Review

The World of Kanako – Review

Showa Fujishima is a former detective. One day, his daughter Kanako, who is a model student, disappears. To find his daughter, he investigates more carefully into his daughter’s life. He then becomes involved in a shocking situation.

Be Sociable, Share!
Attack on Titan: Kuklo Unbound – Review

Attack on Titan: Kuklo Unbound – Review

Kuklo was found as a baby crying in a mass of Titan vomit, amidst the dead titan corpses. He is essentially hated by the people inside the walls. Kuklo, despite his horrible beginnings and a single-functioning eye, also seems to grow unnaturally fast. He parts himself from his past and gambles on the fate of humanity by enlisting in the Survey Corps.

Be Sociable, Share!
Aldnoah.Zero – Review

Aldnoah.Zero – Review

In 1972, an ancient alien hypergate was discovered on the surface of the moon. Using this technology, humanity began migrating to Mars and settling there. After settlers discovered additional advanced technology, the Vers Empire was founded, which claimed Mars and its secrets for themselves. Later, the Vers Empire declared war on Earth, and in 1999, a battle on the Moon’s surface caused the hypergate to explode, shattering the Moon and scattering remnants into a debris belt around the planet.

Be Sociable, Share!
Dramatical Murder – Review

Dramatical Murder – Review

The story takes place many years in the future where the game “Rhyme,” a virtual fighting game, is incredibly popular and people possess “AllMates,” convenient AI computers.

Be Sociable, Share!

Comments

  • Ali

    This is awesome, I finally disagree with one of your reviews lol. While I do understand your position, I just can’t help but love this show. I think it is mainly because I was so caught up in the character interactions that I completely forgot about the other weird plot devices in the show. Plus, as someone who has watched Onegai Teacher, my nostalgia meter was off the charts. I do admit though, in retrospect, that all the sci-fi elements felt foreign and did not matter whatsoever or even play a major role. Personally, I don’t mind these shows where they play it safe and just give us a show we all know well to soak in enjoyment.

  • Jawz

    Looks interesting enough, I think I’ll watch it. I’m not that big into sci fi things but the romance part sounds good, hopefully there’s a tsundere in this show:).

  • Miguel Douglas

    @Ali: Disagreeing with one of my reviews is awesome, lol! I did really enjoy the character interactions within the show, and I can see where you’re coming from from a nostalgic point of view. Perhaps I’ll give the series a re-watch and not be so worried about the whole “extraterrestrial” aspect. I did really like some of the themes within the show though, which I think screenwriter Yosuke Kuroda handled really well.

    @Jawz: Indeed, give it a watch if it interests you. And yes, it does contain a tsundere!

  • http://animereviews.co Nadav

    I agree wholeheatedly with this review. The fact that Ichika is an alien in itself doesn’t add anything to the plot. Since the characters are not very complex it’s easy to see when someone loves the other and this means there is no emotional impact when someone confesses their love. It did feel nostalgic, like the Onegai series did, but it lacked the romantic edge of Onegai Twins or the comedy elements found in Onegai Teacher.

  • j gavin

    i wonder is the show over and is it just me or is this show like a less perverted girls bravo.

  • Chris

    This Anime was amazing… but i hate how it was so short they had a really good love story in it and i can never get enough of it.

  • Nico

    j gavin: The show is over but the manga is still running. I don’t know if the anime had a fitting ending or not as I haven’t seen it yet, but we may see a second season or an OVA.